Posted in 🌻 Blog & Writing Life 🌻, 📚 Writing Tips 📚

Ways to Soften the Impact of a Bad Review

Hello!  Let’s talk about an unpleasant topic that is bound to happen, sooner or later.  That is the topic of a bad review âœï¸ðŸ˜­

Doing writing workshops in college, I noticed that some people would get very emotional over constructive criticism.  Even though we had to find places of improvement in the story.  Even though we were there to learn.

So, besides putting our fingers in our ears and going la la la, what else could we do?

1. Know That it Will Happen, And it is Normal

A book that is 100% loved by 100% of people is rare indeed.  Even books so successful that they are turned to movies receive negative reviews.  You just can’t please all the people, all the time.

Google your favorite book and see the reviews.  Chances are, some are negative.

Even books like Andy Weir’s The Martian receive reviews such as: “MacGyver gets stranded on Mars” and “Main plot is predictable, not really suspenseful.”  (Those were 2-star reviews on Amazon).  It happens, and it is okay.

2. 10% of People Won’t Like You– No Matter What

That statistic works just as well for your writing.  You might have a pretty good piece of writing with a solid story.  Still, some people just won’t like it.

You are not everybody’s cup of tea.  No one is.

In life, it is foolish to aim for everyone to like us.  The same applies to writing.  Over time, you will build an audience that gels very well with your writing.  But that audience won’t be the whole entire world.

3. They Are Criticizing the Story, Not You Personally

I offended a girl at a workshop because I criticized a boring character, and it turned out she had modeled him after herself.  Well, you can be boring in real life, but I was talking about the character!

Criticism of plot, characters, setting, or anything else has to do with the story– not you as a person.

And I know some stories come straight from the heart, but there is still a big difference between you as a person and what is on paper.  When a negative review stings, realize that it is something about the story they did not enjoy.  You are still intact as a person.

4. Try to See Their Point of View

This is an important one for beginners like me (and maybe you).  And especially if you keep seeing the same repeat negative comment.

When you read a negative review, consider if it is something that will actually help you improve your writing.

If people keep saying it was hard to picture your setting, you might have to work a bit more on that.  If people are saying your characters are all the same, you might want to take a closer look at that.  Negative reviews can truly be an opportunity for improvement.

5. Forget Any Incoherent Negative Reviews

 While you should definitely consider the criticism, you certainly don’t have to consider all of it.  I’ve gotten some great feedback that was negative, and some not-so-great feedback that was negative.

Whatever, it’s stupid, I didn’t even read it.

☝️😑 That, my friends, is a real 1-star review I received on one of my short stories.  These happen, and they are useless.  Better to forget it and move on (though this one was particularly hard to forget.  You… didn’t even read it! ðŸ˜²)

Negative reviews are unpleasant, but we can power through them.

Even if you completely bomb and receive mostly negative feedback, there is always the next book.  Take the good, constructive advice and leave the rest behind!

Got any tips to soothe the sting?  Let us know in the comments ðŸ“š

Take care and write on,

YariGarciaWrites

🌸 🌜🌸 🌜🌸 🌜🌸 🌜🌸 🌜🌸 🌜🌸 🌜

Author:

I'm an indie author sharing my journey of creativity and faith.

12 thoughts on “Ways to Soften the Impact of a Bad Review

  1. Some great tips here, Yari. Negative reviews can be crushing, but we mustn’t let them affect our dreams and ambitions. As you say, there will always be some who criticise, and some who do so in nasty way. Best to accept this as part of the process of being a writer/author. Once we accept it happens to everyone, it doesn’t seem so bad 😊

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thanks, Steven 🙂 You’re right. I think it’s important, especially for new authors, to accept this, since we’re putting our best work out there… but we are still pretty new at this!

      Keep writing, keep improving. That’s the way I see it 🙂

      Take care,
      Yari

      Liked by 1 person

  2. Such great advice here! 😀 So glad you shared this – it’s really easy to slip into a negative bias and only focus on the poor reviews rather than the glowing ones. To soothe the sting, I’ve kept reminding myself that a Bad Review is still…a Review. One person who thinks that. It’s not a make-or-break opinion.
    Say out of 10 reviews, 1 person was absolutely scathing of it. That’s still an amazing ratio, just think: 90% of your reviewers like it, enjoyed it or flat out loved it! No book’s ever going to receive only good reviews over a lifetime, or please all readers. Whatever you do, keep writing, keep improving, and don’t give up! ❤

    Liked by 1 person

  3. All of these. I’ve gotten bad reviews, and I’ve left negative reviews. It is a review of the book, not the author. Even the hugely popular books have bad reviews. And that’s okay. It’s okay for people to have different opinions of things.

    But, as a writer, we can’t let one or a few bad reviews get in the way. The more reviews a book receives overall, the more bad reviews they will receive, too.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I’ve left negative reviews too. Thinking about that has also helped me understand that a negative review is very impersonal. I was never thinking of the author while writing a less-than-five-star review, I was just thinking of a few things I didn’t care for in the story.

      And great point! More reviews is definitely an overall good thing~ especially for indie authors.

      Take care,
      Yari

      Like

  4. How can you review review something you didn’t read, though? Does that even make any sense? 😂 The person who reviewed your short story has some guts.

    You’ve shared helpful tips, Yari. We shouldn’t take criticisms and negative reviews personally, but we can always filter the honest criticisms and let them give us an opportunity to improve ourselves.

    We can’t please everyone. Heck, even the Harry Potter series got a few negative reviews.

    Getting negative reviews is something every writer will face at some point in time, eventually. Best to accept this hard truth. 😊

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I thought that was incredibly silly too, but oh well 🙂 It kind of makes me laugh now 😏

      My audience has been YA for a time (though I’m switching genres) and they can be super-honest and direct! Their brutally honest feedback has definitely helped me improve~ very true.

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s